Season 4 Shorty #1

As we put the finishing touches on season 4, we're giving you a few Shorties to keep you busy. Question of the day: What to do when you run into someone before your scheduled first date?! Subscribe now via iTunes or your favorite podcast player! For more information,...

Season 4 Preview

It's time for a taste of season 4. Get excited for more dating catastrophes, and an ode to Alan Thicke. Subscribe now via iTunes or your favorite podcast player! For more information, go to toooldtodate.com. Hit us up on the socials @toooldtodate. Visit...

Episode 24 – Michael Abides

Mike's summer of love comes to an overwhelming conclusion. Brad makes a last ditch effort to win over Tiana, but gets the suspicion that he's being pushed from one woman to another. Written by Brad Garoon & Mike Tanzillo Additional Voices by Dara Pollack, Trinity...

Episode 23 – Thanks, Rwanda

Brad and Mike have very different experiences going out with two different women who are only in town for a limited amount of time. Written by Brad Garoon &  Mike Tanzillo Additional Voices by Dara Pollack & Nikki Tomaino Narration by Susan Khan Our theme song...

Episode 22 – Giggle Stick

Emily, a woman with whom Brad shares a therapist, navigates the complicated world of workplace relationships. Written by Brad Garoon,  Mike Tanzillo, and Cher Landman Additional Voices by Jennie Kamin, Rokhsane Mahmoudi, Christopher Freda, and Lauren Weber Narration...

Episode 21 – Three Waves

A ride share taxi exposes Mike & Brad to a handful of New York City's more troubled young people. Written by Brad Garoon & Mike Tanzillo Additional Voices by Jen Greenwald, Simon Dick, Brandon Lamar, Christine Perrella, Megan Gentry, Chelsea Alison, Jeannine...

Episode 20 – Second Pizza

Brad and Mike vie for the affections of the same waitress, while Abby and James explain their unique relationship history. Written by Brad Garoon & Mike Tanzillo Additional Voices by Jen Greenwald, Simon Dick, Abby Green & James Li Narration by Susan Khan Our...

Episode 19 – Island Avenue

Amber visits Jeff at his parents' vacation home in Miami, but is it too soon to be going on a vacation date with him? Written by Brad Garoon & Mike Tanzillo Additional Voices by Chelsea Alison, Haven Cousins, Madison Landis, and Nina Modelski Narration by Susan...

Episode 18 – Dating Data

Brad goes on a "Skype date" with a girl across the country. Written by Brad Garoon & Mike Tanzillo Additional Voices by Carin Fishel Narration by Susan Khan Our theme song is Loveless by Go Go Ghost Subscribe now via iTunes or your favorite podcast player! For...

Episode 17 – Five Steps

Mike looks to his older brother for advice on getting over his divorce. Brad runs into a familiar face. Written by Brad Garoon & Mike Tanzillo Additional Voices by Jamie Bliss & PJ Tanzillo Narration by Susan Khan Our theme song is Loveless by Go Go Ghost...

Episode 16 – Dental Surgery

Mike & Brad, feeling upset about the women who appear to be ghosting them, use Tinder Social to go on an impromptu double date. Later, Brad finally confronts Kelly, and Mike gets some bad news from Alisha. Written by Brad Garoon & Mike Tanzillo Additional...

Episode 15 – Latex Catsuit

Amber tells Brad and Mike about her fear of revealing her sexual fetishes to Kyle. Brad suggests she practice on new friend Jeff. Written by Dara Pollak, Brad Garoon & Mike Tanzillo Additional Voices by Chelsea Alison & Haven Cousins Narration by Susan Khan...

Episode 14 – Charity Turkey

Brad and Mike discover their civic sides while examining a peculiar email. Mike reconnects with an old crush. Written by Brad Garoon & Mike Tanzillo Additional Voices by Brie Tse Narration by Susan Khan Our theme song is Loveless by Go Go Ghost Subscribe now via...

Episode 13 – Luke’s Orgy

Brad tries to get closer to Kelly in Nashville, while Mike contemplates going to a sex party in New York. Written by Brad Garoon & Mike Tanzillo Additional Voices by Jenna Heller, Jason Emmendorfer, and Matt Hornback Narration by Susan Khan Our theme song is...

Episode 12 – Dusky Dudes

Hannah tries to convince Peter to remove the dating apps from his phone, and is troubled when establishing relationship labels. Then, Pritha teaches Hannah about Shaadi and Indian arranged marriages online. Written by Jessica Rosen, Brad Garoon, & Mike Tanzillo...

Episode 11 – Lobby Notes

Brad makes a bold move in Queens, while Mike tries to meet women off of the dating apps in Manhattan. Written by Brad Garoon, & Mike Tanzillo Additional Voices by Jenna Heller, Kevin Thomason, Christopher Freda, and Rick Rosenbluth Narration by Susan Khan Our...

Episode 10 – Bee Stings

Mike deals with a potentially racist date. Brad deals with a bee infestation and his own body image issues. Written by Brad Garoon, & Mike Tanzillo Additional Voices by Haven Cousins, Linda Chang, and Samantha Tugentmen Narration by Susan Khan Our theme song is...

Episode 9 – Golden Toilet

Mike and Brad have a falling out. Brad catches up with his cousin Carter, while Mike gets some troubling dental news. Written by Brad Garoon, & Mike Tanzillo Additional Voices by David Kang, Isaac Holze, and Ronna Feldman Narration by Susan Khan Our theme song is...

Episode 8 – Brittany… My Name is Brittany

Mike makes first contact with a woman he's been trying to meet for a very long time. Bradley struggles with a recent loss, and a fading romance. Written by Brad Garoon, & Michael Tanzillo Production Assistance by Toby Singer Additional Voices by Erica Cho...

Episode 7 – Piddle Pads

Mike has a persistent visitor, and Brad's desire for adventure goes disastrously awry. Written by Brad Garoon, & Michael Tanzillo Production Assistance by Toby Singer Additional Voices by Chelsea Townsend and Aaron Gottlieb Narration by Susan Khan Our theme song...

Share This