Madison, 22
Madison is a new bartender at Mike and Brad’s favorite bar, working with Rob. She is studying occupational therapy and lives with an ex boyfriend in New Jersey.
Season 2: Brad is interested in Madison, but she is more interested in Mike. Mike ends up taking her home and learning more than he bargained for about her. Brad worries that Mike’s hookup with Madison will ruin their experience at their favorite bar, but Madison quits out of nowhere.
Appearances: Second Pizza; Three Waves
Portrayed by: Jen Greenwald